Best Pizza in Liverpool: Your Guide to the Tastiest Slices in the City

Best Pizza in Liverpool

Pizza holds a special place in the heart of many food lovers in Liverpool. The city boasts a plethora of restaurants that serve exceptional pizza, bringing joy to the taste buds of locals and visitors alike. With National Pizza Day fast approaching, it’s the perfect time to explore the top pizza joints that Liverpool has to offer.

From classic Italian pizzerias like Otto’s and Casa Italia to inventive and mouth-watering options at Santa Maluco and The Peacock, Liverpool truly caters to every pizza lover’s dream. This list of exceptional pizza establishments spans diverse flavours, regional traditions, and unique combinations, ensuring that there is a slice for everyone to savour and enjoy in this vibrant city.

1. The Peacock

Located on Seel Street, The Peacock is a superb bar and pizzeria featuring an outdoor terrace on St Peter’s Square. Every pizza is freshly prepared before your eyes, ensuring a delicious and satisfying experience.

The menu boasts unique toppings, such as a breakfast-inspired combination of sausage, egg, bacon, and mushrooms, as well as the fiery Los Hermanos. To enhance your pizza experience, don’t forget to request a stuffed crust for that extra cheesy indulgence – a feature that helps set The Peacock apart as one of Liverpool’s top pizza destinations.

Address: 51 Seel St, L1 4AZ

2. American Pizza Slice

When it comes to pizza in Liverpool, American Pizza Slice stands out as the top choice for authentic New York-style pizza. With three locations across the city – Bold Street, Whitechapel, and South Road – it’s an ideal spot for grabbing a quick bite while shopping, on a lunch break, or even on your way home after an evening out.

The talented team at American Pizza Slice not only offers single slices but also whole 18-inch pizzas to satisfy those with a bigger appetite. To complement the scrumptious pizza, an impressive selection of craft beers is available for patrons to enjoy. Head to 122 Bold Street L1 4JA for an unforgettable pizza experience in Liverpool.

3. Nightcrawler Pizza @ The Merchant

Providing an 80s ambiance, Nightcrawler Pizza at The Merchant delivers unique retro pizza selections in their dough bar situated at the intersection of Slater Street and Parr Street. Connected to The Merchant bar, this intimate, tiled room serves delectable, affordable pizzas to both partygoers and passersby.

Nightcrawler constantly updates their menu and offers a range of tasty accompaniments for customers to personalise their pizza. The atmospheric neon pink lighting and eclectic décor create a perfect setting for an after-pizza photo opportunity.

Location: 28 Slater St, L1 4BX

4. Amalia

Located just off Duke Street on Campbell Square, Amalia Italian restaurant in Liverpool has gained immense popularity for its delicious pizza. In fact, it was awarded the title of the ‘Best Pizza in England’ in 2017, placing it among the top choices for pizza in the city.

Amalia serves a diverse range of Italian dishes but is particularly renowned for its traditional Neapolitan pizzas. Customers who visit can enjoy classic options such as Pollo al Caprino and Quattro Stagioni. But a must-try item on their menu is their delectable Calzone.

For those who are both brave and hungry, Amalia offers the Calzone Challenge. Successfully completing this challenge entails devouring a massive 5lb calzone packed with vegetables, meat, tomato, and an abundance of cheese. Victorious challengers will get the calzone for free!

5. Casa Italia

Located in Liverpool’s business district, Casa Italia is a well-known restaurant famous for its incredible, heavenly-tasting 12-inch pizzas. With a history of attracting long queues and patronage from notable individuals like Paul McCartney, Liam Gallagher, and Robbie Williams, this Italian eatery has enjoyed enduring popularity over the years. Casa Italia holds the title of one of Liverpool’s longest-established restaurants, proudly serving delicious Italian food to both locals and visitors alike. Visit them at 26-40 Stanley St, L1 6AL for a truly delightful pizza experience.

6. Crust

Discover the delightful independent restaurant Crust, located on Bold Street, offering contemporary takes on traditional Italian dishes. Enjoy an unmatched level of pizza customisation with five distinct crust variations, including a nutritious five-grain option and the unique black dough, and a selection of over 30 toppings.

Indulge in the lavish Gamberi & Astice, featuring prawns, lobster, and lobster sauce, or the rich Straccetti, with sliced fillet mignon, rocket, parmesan, and cherry tomatoes for a luxurious pizza experience in Liverpool.

25 Bold St L1 4HR and 3 Allerton Road, Woolton Road L25 7RA

7. Rudy’s Pizza

Rudy’s Pizza prides itself on being solely focused on creating delicious pizzas. Every day, their dedicated team prepares the renowned dough on-site, crafting soft, flavourful, and authentic pizzas that truly resemble homemade Italian masterpieces.

Pizza lovers can indulge in a variety of toppings, such as the Tarantina with tomatoes, anchovies, capers, and olives, or the Romagnolo comprised of rocket, prosciutto crudo, and parmesan. For a different twist, Rudy’s also offers white pizzas without tomato bases.

Located at 3-7 Castle Street, L2 4SW, Rudy’s is the perfect destination for experiencing true Neapolitan delights.

8. The Italian Club

The Italian Club, situated on Bold Street in Liverpool, prides itself on serving authentic Italian cuisine. A popular destination for individuals seeking genuine pizza and pasta dishes, this family-operated establishment guarantees an exceptional dining experience by sourcing many ingredients directly from Italy.

Upon entering The Italian Club, guests are welcomed into a warm, home-like atmosphere that reflects the classic Italian tradition of serving dishes as they become ready. For a delightful and memorable Italian meal, visit The Italian Club at 85 Bold Street, L1 4HF.

9. Dough Bar

Dough Bar, a venture by The Font, offers delicious cheese-laden delights to both locals and university students in Liverpool. Although its location is hidden within a Liverpool University dormitory, the unassuming spot satisfies cravings with their tasty offerings.

Address: Grand Central, Hilbre St, L3 5GA

10. Trattoria 51

For those working in the commercial district and seeking a delicious lunch spot, Trattoria 51 has you covered. Located on Old Hall Street, this establishment serves 12-inch stone-baked pizzas with no frills; just authentic, traditional flavours. The delightful simplicity of their pizzas showcases that sometimes, simplicity truly is the best approach.

With the margherita pizza, crafted to mimic the Italian tricolore, Trattoria 51 offers one of the finest slices you’ll find in Liverpool.

Address: 25-31 Old Hall Street, Liverpool, L3 9BS

11. Il Forno

At the distinguished Il Forno, Italian cuisine is elevated through its fine dining experience. Located on Duke Street, this sophisticated restaurant is led by Head Chef Paolo Cillo. He strives to deliver an authentic Italian experience to Liverpool by blending time-honoured Italian tradition with his own inventive flair.

Indulge in a meal at one of the top Italian restaurants in the nation and enjoy expertly crafted dishes like the San Daniele, featuring mozzarella, tomato, and Parma ham. Alternatively, try one of Cillo’s standout gourmet creations, such as the Tartufo – a plain pizza base adorned with marinated beef, black truffle, truffle cheese, and a mostarda dressing.

132 Duke St, L1 5AG

12. Ma Egerton’s Stage Door

Located next to the Empire Theatre’s backstage entrance, Ma Egerton’s Stage Door attracts visitors with its fantastic Italian-style stone base pizzas. Each pizza is named after iconic celebrities such as Charlie Chaplin, Marilyn Monroe, and Henry “The Fonze” Winkler, offering a star-studded dining experience.

This historic pub, established in the early 20th century, honours its landlady and theatrical agent, Ma Egerton, who hosted prominent performers like Tom Jones, Judy Garland, and Harry Houdini. As you relish a scrumptious slice, immerse yourself in the rich cultural heritage of Liverpool’s theatre district, once centred around Lime Street.

Address: 9 Pudsey St, L1 1JA

13. Fredericks

Nestled on the historic Hope Street, Fredericks offers a carefully crafted selection of pizzas in Liverpool. Their menu features unique options like Char Sui pulled pork and pepper with a hoi sin base or a chargrilled vegetables and feta pizza with pesto.

Guests can choose to sit outdoors, admiring the captivating views of both the Anglican and Metropolitan cathedrals, or step inside to savour their pizza by a cosy open fire with a cold beer. For an added experience, visit on a Wednesday to enjoy live jazz while indulging in a scrumptious slice.

32 Hope St L1 9BX

14. Love & Rockets

Located in the heart of Liverpool’s vibrant Lark Lane, Love & Rockets offers some of the best pizza in the city. Patrons can indulge in creative options such as fried chicken, pineapple, brie, and grape toppings, or savour the classic flavours of a scrumptious margherita. Make sure to visit Love & Rockets at 52 Lark Ln, L17 8UU for a memorable pizza experience.

15. Little Furnace

For those seeking a true taste of classic pizza without over-the-top toppings, Little Furnace offers an exceptional choice. Having impressed customers at various pop-up events across the city, this highly sought-after Liverpool pizzeria has now established a permanent location on Smithdown Road.

Visit their Smithdown Road venue or the Baltic Market to enjoy authentic wood-fired pizzas cooked to perfection, showcasing high-quality ingredients.

Among the many pizza options in Liverpool, Little Furnace certainly stands out as one of the finest.

178 Smithdown Rd, L15 3JR and Baltic Market, Cains Brewery, Stanhope Street, L8 5XJ

16. Crazy Pedros

For those seeking unique and daring pizza flavours in Liverpool, Crazy Pedros is the place to be. With a reputation for creating unconventional pizza toppings, this venue guarantees an unforgettable culinary experience.

Crazy Pedros caters to junk food enthusiasts, offering mouth-watering options such as fried chicken and the notable hotdog pizza. Located at 25 Parr St, L1 4JN, this pizza joint is sure to impress with its bold, flavourful creations.